By attachment, before anything else. A magnetic bag needs a steel tank — plenty of modern machines have plastic or aluminium ones. Straps fit anything and cross the paint. A ring system is specific to your machine and the quickest to release.
Establish what your tank is made of
This is the single most common mismatched purchase in the family. A magnet on a plastic or aluminium tank holds nothing, and the tank material is not always obvious from looking. The manual or the maker answers it.
What each attachment costs you
Magnetic: fastest to fit and remove, and it traps grit against the paint if the tank is not clean. Strap: universal, slower, and webbing crosses painted surfaces. Ring: a ring replaces the fuel cap surround and the bag clips to it — most secure, fastest release, and a two-part purchase because the ring is machine-specific.
Capacity, and the part that is published as a range
Many bags expand with a zip, which is why capacity is often given as two numbers. An expanded bag sits higher, which matters if you lean forward — worth checking against your own riding position rather than a photograph.
The features that decide daily use
A top pocket that can be worked with gloves on. A carry strap, because the bag comes off at every stop and has to go somewhere. And a waterproof cover, almost always supplied and almost never as good as a sealed bag — which is worth knowing before a long wet day.
Where makers help and where they do not
Those who list compatible machines have done the work for you. Where no list exists, the tank shape in your own case is what decides, and a photograph of a different tank tells you nothing.
Questions riders send in about this
Will a magnetic bag scratch the tank?
Grit trapped underneath will. A clean tank and a clean bag base are what prevent it, and it is the reason many riders prefer straps or a ring.
Can a tank bag block the filler?
Some do, and makers who have solved it publish that the bag opens or lifts for refuelling. It is worth checking before a trip rather than at a pump.
Last reviewed 18 September 2026